1,770
edits
118Wiki:Featured Articles: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
archiving Thor Deck Layout discussion
(→Thor Deck Layout: Updated date of opposition comment) Tags: Mobile edit Mobile web edit |
(archiving Thor Deck Layout discussion) |
||
| (13 intermediate revisions by 7 users not shown) | |||
| Line 16: | Line 16: | ||
:''Please place each candidate article title as a linked level 3 header (like <nowiki>===[[this]]===</nowiki>) below this italicised instruction text. The newest candidate is to be placed nearest the top. Please add '''Support''', '''Oppose''' or '''Comment''' in bold in front of your first constructive comment in reply to an article name and stamp each comment with 4 tildes <nowiki>~~~~</nowiki>. If you wish to switch your opinion, strikethrough your previous stance (by surrounding with <nowiki><s> and </s></nowiki> <s>'''like this'''</s>) and post your new stance before your comment.'' | :''Please place each candidate article title as a linked level 3 header (like <nowiki>===[[this]]===</nowiki>) below this italicised instruction text. The newest candidate is to be placed nearest the top. Please add '''Support''', '''Oppose''' or '''Comment''' in bold in front of your first constructive comment in reply to an article name and stamp each comment with 4 tildes <nowiki>~~~~</nowiki>. If you wish to switch your opinion, strikethrough your previous stance (by surrounding with <nowiki><s> and </s></nowiki> <s>'''like this'''</s>) and post your new stance before your comment.'' | ||
===[[ | ===[[Writing Improvement Squadron]]=== | ||
'''Support | '''Support''' This page gives a number of resources for people who wish to improve their writing. I even refer to this page from time to time as a refresher and think it's helpful even after ten years in this group! [[User:Alora DeVeau|Alora DeVeau]] ([[User talk:Alora DeVeau|talk]]) 18:32, 9 July 2024 (EDT) | ||
''' | '''Comment:''' It's a good page, in that it links to a lot of other, very useful pages... But I'm not sure that as a ''page'' itself, it's really worthy of being promoted as a Featured Article? I'd like to have more discussion on this at least. [[User:Gnai|Gnai]] ([[User talk:Gnai|talk]]) 17:17, 10 July 2024 (UTC) | ||
'''Comment''': I agree with Gnai's current sentiment here, but I do think some of the pages linked to on this page could make for good nominations themselves! [[User:Niev Galanis|Niev Galanis]] ([[User talk:Niev Galanis|talk]]) 06:47, 12 July 2024 (UTC) | |||
'''Oppose:'' | '''Oppose''': As the others have already said, this is a good and important page, but it's not a particularly good article; it's not an article to begin with, but rather an index of articles. The featured articles are judged by specific criteria, and those criteria just aren't applicable to this page. It should be spammed everywhere so even the most wiki adverse cadets can find it, but I don't think it should be promoted to an FA. --[[User:Jovenan|Jovenan]] ([[User talk:Jovenan|talk]]) 20:57, 12 July 2024 (UTC) | ||
===[[Robin Hopper]]=== | |||
'''Support as nominator:''' I think this nomination speaks for itself, even if only going by how many character pages have borrowed from or been inspired by Robin's page. It's beautifully done, and very comprehensive. [[User:Gnai|Gnai]] ([[User talk:Gnai|talk]]) 19:42, 9 July 2024 (UTC) | |||
'''Support''': As one of the people that leaned a lot on Robin's page to get my character page looking nice, I also support this! It's a great example of a thorough, great-looking profile that inspires people to better their own. [[User:Niev Galanis|Niev Galanis]] ([[User talk:Niev Galanis|talk]]) 06:47, 12 July 2024 (UTC) | |||
==[[Image:LinkFA-star.png]] [[:Category:Featured Articles|Featured Articles]]== | ==[[Image:LinkFA-star.png]] [[:Category:Featured Articles|Featured Articles]]== | ||
| Line 30: | Line 36: | ||
[[Karawati]]''' · '''[[Previous ships called Independence]]''' | [[Karawati]]''' · '''[[Previous ships called Independence]]''' | ||
===Locations=== | ===Locations=== | ||
[[StarBase 118]]''' · '''[[Ithassa Region]]''' | [[The Shoals]]''' · '''[[StarBase 118]]''' · '''[[Ithassa Region]]''' | ||
===Characters=== | ===Characters=== | ||
:''See also: [[Featured Bio Contest]]'' | :''See also: [[Featured Bio Contest]]'' | ||