Featured Bio Contest Minimum Selection Criteria: Difference between revisions

From 118Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(removed reference to minimum selection criteria (changed to judging criteria))
m (Rich moved page Featured Bio Contest Judging Criteria to Featured Bio Contest Minimum Selection Criteria over redirect: Minimum Selection criteria reinstated by new facilitator LtCmdr Jorey)
 
(6 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{FBCsidebar}}
{{FBCsidebar}}
All featured articles recognized by the Featured Bio Contest must meet the contest's '''Judging Criteria'''.
All articles nominated for consideration in the Featured Bio Contest are judged using the contest's '''Judging Criteria''' as a guide. The winning bio does not need to meet all aspects of the criteria, but past winners tend to exhibit these elements.


==Preface==
==Preface==
Line 6: Line 6:
|- valign="top"
|- valign="top"
|bgcolor="#F5FAFF" style="border:1px solid #CEDFF2; padding:1em; padding-top:0.5em; padding-bottom:0em; color: black;"|
|bgcolor="#F5FAFF" style="border:1px solid #CEDFF2; padding:1em; padding-top:0.5em; padding-bottom:0em; color: black;"|
Before we get to the judging criteria, the Featured Bio Contest Team would first like to iterate that the following criteria are '''the minimum.'''
The purpose of giving you this list of items isn't to stifle your creativity with your articles. In deciding just what should be considered the ideal for this contest, all ship/station rosters were surveyed to see how different members have chosen to present their characters. The following list represents some of the common elements noted across the board, yet the end result can and is often quite different and individual. For instance, consider the following three articles:


Second, the purpose of giving you this list of items isn't to stifle your creativity with your articles. In deciding just what should be considered the minimum for this contest, all ship/station rosters were surveyed to see how different members have chosen to present their characters. The following list represents some of the common elements noted across the board, yet the end result can and is often quite different and individual. For instance, consider the following three articles:
*[[DeVeau, Alora|Alora DeVeau]]
 
*[[Blake, Sky|Sky Blake]]
*[[Nicholotti, Kali|Kali Nicholotti]]
*[[Nicholotti, Kali|Kali Nicholotti]]
*[[Whale, David|David Whale]]
*[[Whale, David|David Whale]]
Line 16: Line 14:
Each of these articles includes the elements listed in the criteria yet each showcases the character in a distinct fashion. If anything, we hope the criteria may perhaps inspire you and other members to expand your articles in a way that will let any reader learn more about your characters and the adventures that they have had during their time in our fleet.
Each of these articles includes the elements listed in the criteria yet each showcases the character in a distinct fashion. If anything, we hope the criteria may perhaps inspire you and other members to expand your articles in a way that will let any reader learn more about your characters and the adventures that they have had during their time in our fleet.


Inquiries about the criteria may be posted in this [http://www.starbase118.net/forums/index.php?/topic/7384-minimum-selection-criteria-for-featured-articles/ thread] in the contest's forum.
Inquiries about the criteria may be posted in this [http://forums.starbase118.net/index.php?/topic/9501-featured-bio-competition-judging-criteria// thread] in the contest's forum.


Good luck!
Good luck!
Line 23: Line 21:
|}
|}
==Judging Criteria for Featured Articles==
==Judging Criteria for Featured Articles==
The ideal featured bio...
#Must be of a '''player character''' played by a '''current and active member'''.
#Must be of a '''player character''' played by a '''current and active member'''.
#Must be either a '''primary''' or '''secondary''' player character. '''PNPCs are ineligible'''.
#Must be either a '''primary''' or '''secondary''' player character. '''PNPCs are ineligible'''.
#All information in the article must be '''current as of the submission date'''.
#Includes information about the character that is '''current as of the submission date'''.
#Must include both a link to the character’s '''current ship''' in the '''first sentence''' of the article and a template box with the '''current ship’s roster''' at the '''bottom''' of the article.
#Includes both a link to the character’s '''current ship''' in the '''first sentence''' of the article and a template box with the '''current ship’s roster''' at the '''bottom''' of the article.
#Must include a '''full professional history''' of the character, showing rank progression, previous duty posts, and previous assignments.
#Includes an '''appearance section'''.
#Must include an '''appearance section'''.
#Includes a '''relationships section''' with a link to at least '''one different simmer’s player character'''.
#Must include a '''relationships section''' with a link to at least '''one different simmer’s player character'''.
#Includes some '''description''' of the character’s '''background, personality, or career history'''.
#Must include an '''awards section''' showing any awards or service ribbons the character has received '''if applicable'''. This section should also include '''links to the “[[List of Awards]]” and “[[Service Ribbons]]” articles'''. The links may be incorporated into the section heading, as part of a table subheading, or listed separately.
#Includes a '''full professional history''' of the character, showing rank progression, previous duty posts, and previous assignments.
#Must include some '''description''' of the character’s '''background, personality, or career history'''.
#Includes an '''awards section''' showing any awards or service ribbons the character has received '''if applicable'''. This section should also include '''links to the “[[List of Awards]]” and “[[Service Ribbons]]” articles'''. The links may be incorporated into the section heading, as part of a table subheading, or listed separately.
#Must include links to at least '''two (2) selected sims''' written from the character’s perspective.
#Includes links to at least '''two (2) selected sims''' written from the character’s perspective.
#Must be '''properly categorized''' into at least the '''following five categories''':
#Is '''properly categorized''' into at least the '''following five categories''':
##'''[[:Category:Characters|Characters]]'''
##'''[[:Category:Characters|Characters]]'''
##'''Affiliation''' (e.g., [[:Category:Starfleet personnel|Starfleet personnel]], [[:Category:Civilians|Civilians]])
##'''Affiliation''' (e.g., [[:Category:Starfleet personnel|Starfleet personnel]], [[:Category:Civilians|Civilians]])
##'''Ship/Station PCs''' (e.g., [[:Category:USS Avandar PCs|USS Avandar PCs]])
##'''Ship/Station PCs''' (e.g., [[:Category:Avandar PCs|Avandar PCs]])
##'''[[:Category:Individuals by occupation|Profession]]''' (e.g., [[:Category:HCO Officers|HCO Officers]], [[:Category:Scientists|Scientists]])
##'''[[:Category:Individuals by occupation|Profession]]''' (e.g., [[:Category:HCO Officers|HCO Officers]], [[:Category:Scientists|Scientists]])
##'''[[:Category:Individuals by species|Species]]''' (e.g., [[:Category:Vulcans|Vulcans]], [[:Category:Caitians|Caitians]])
##'''[[:Category:Individuals by species|Species]]''' (e.g., [[:Category:Vulcans|Vulcans]], [[:Category:Caitians|Caitians]])
Line 49: Line 48:




'''3. All information in the article must be current as of the submission date.'''
'''3. Includes information about the character that is current as of the submission date.'''
 
 
'''4. Must include both a link to the character’s current ship in the first sentence of the article and a template box with the current ship’s roster at the bottom of the article.'''




'''5. Must include a full professional history of the character, showing rank progression, previous duty posts, and previous assignments.'''
'''4. Includes both a link to the character’s current ship in the first sentence of the article and a template box with the current ship’s roster at the bottom of the article.'''
*Showing the professional history of the character shows both other members and prospective members how each of our simmers started at ensign and worked their way up to their current rank.
*Note, while this is the reasoning to include this criterion, the professional history does not necessarily have to match the actual professional history of the simmer in the event that the featured article character is a secondary or a replacement primary character. A “fictional” professional history leading to their first SB118 ship/station is acceptable.




'''6. Must include an appearance section.'''
'''5. Includes an appearance section.'''
*While many of our members create images of their characters, we understand if others cannot or do not wish to do so. However, the article still must include information on the character’s appearance. The simmer may decide how much information they wish to include, but they must include at least one description such as height.
*While many of our members create images of their characters, we understand if others cannot or do not wish to do so. However, the article still must include information on the character’s appearance. The simmer may decide how much information they wish to include, but they must include at least one description such as height.




'''7. Must include a relationships section with a link to at least one different simmer’s player character.'''
'''6. Includes a relationships section with a link to at least one different simmer’s player character.'''
*Again, the purpose of this project is to feature our members and our community, encouraging both current and prospective members to learn more about our group. One of the best ways to do this is to encourage them to explore the SB118 Wiki itself.
*Again, the purpose of this project is to feature our members and our community, encouraging both current and prospective members to learn more about our group. One of the best ways to do this is to encourage them to explore the SB118 Wiki itself.
*A relationships section that includes information about friendships or romances should include at least one link to a different simmer’s primary/secondary player character (again, not a PNPC).
*A relationships section that includes information about friendships or romances should include at least one link to a different simmer’s primary/secondary player character (again, not a PNPC).
Line 70: Line 64:




'''8. Must include an awards section showing any awards or service ribbons the character has received if applicable. This section should also include links to the “[[List of Awards]]” and “[[Service Ribbons]]” articles. The links may be incorporated into the section heading, as part of a table subheading, or listed separately.'''
'''7. Includes some description of the character’s background, personality, or career history.'''
*Our [[Community Awards|Fleet Awards]] are a proud tradition to recognize our members. Including this section should encourage more members to learn about the awards and nominate their fellow members for consideration when the annual awards ceremony approaches.
 
 
'''9. Must include some description of the character’s background, personality, or career history.'''
*Of course, we don’t want featured articles to just be a list of facts and awards. There should be some written description of either the character’s backstory or time since they’ve been in the SB118 fleet.
*Of course, we don’t want featured articles to just be a list of facts and awards. There should be some written description of either the character’s backstory or time since they’ve been in the SB118 fleet.
*Ideally, readers should be able to get just from reading the descriptive text a sense of what kind of person the character is and what kind of adventures and missions he or she has had since joining SB118. The tables or chronological listing of past assignments in the professional history should be used more as a supplement to the text.
*Ideally, readers should be able to get just from reading the descriptive text a sense of what kind of person the character is and what kind of adventures and missions he or she has had since joining SB118. The tables or chronological listing of past assignments in the professional history should be used more as a supplement to the text.
Line 80: Line 70:




'''10. Must include links to at least two (2) selected sims written from the character’s perspective.'''
'''8. Includes a full professional history of the character, showing rank progression, previous duty posts, and previous assignments.'''
*Showing the professional history of the character shows both other members and prospective members how each of our simmers started at ensign and worked their way up to their current rank.
*Note, while this is the reasoning to include this criterion, the professional history does not necessarily have to match the actual professional history of the simmer in the event that the featured article character is a secondary or a replacement primary character. A “fictional” professional history leading to their first SB118 ship/station is acceptable.
 
 
'''9. Includes an awards section showing any awards or service ribbons the character has received if applicable. This section should also include links to the “[[List of Awards]]” and “[[Service Ribbons]]” articles. The links may be incorporated into the section heading, as part of a table subheading, or listed separately.'''
*Our [[Community Awards|Fleet Awards]] are a proud tradition to recognize our members. Including this section should encourage more members to learn about the awards and nominate their fellow members for consideration when the annual awards ceremony approaches.
 
 
'''10. Includes links to at least two (2) selected sims written from the character’s perspective.'''
*Links to selected sims from the character’s perspective may either by listed within the descriptive text or listed in either a subsection of the character history or a separate section entirely.
*Links to selected sims from the character’s perspective may either by listed within the descriptive text or listed in either a subsection of the character history or a separate section entirely.




'''11. Must be properly categorized into at least the following five categories:'''
'''11. Is properly categorized into at least the following five categories:'''
#'''[[:Category:Characters|Characters]]'''
#'''[[:Category:Characters|Characters]]'''
#'''Affiliation''' (e.g., [[:Category:Starfleet personnel|Starfleet personnel]], [[:Category:Civilians|Civilians]])
#'''Affiliation''' (e.g., [[:Category:Starfleet personnel|Starfleet personnel]], [[:Category:Civilians|Civilians]])
#'''Ship/Station PCs''' (e.g., [[:Category:USS Avandar PCs|USS Avandar PCs]])
#'''Ship/Station PCs''' (e.g., [[:Category:Avandar PCs|Avandar PCs]])
#'''[[:Category:Individuals by occupation|Profession]]''' (e.g., [[:Category:HCO Officers|HCO Officers]], [[:Category:Scientists|Scientists]])
#'''[[:Category:Individuals by occupation|Profession]]''' (e.g., [[:Category:HCO Officers|HCO Officers]], [[:Category:Scientists|Scientists]])
#'''[[:Category:Individuals by species|Species]]''' (e.g., [[:Category:Vulcans|Vulcans]], [[:Category:Caitians|Caitians]])
#'''[[:Category:Individuals by species|Species]]''' (e.g., [[:Category:Vulcans|Vulcans]], [[:Category:Caitians|Caitians]])
Line 94: Line 93:


==Quick Checklist of the Criteria==
==Quick Checklist of the Criteria==
Thinking of nominating an article? Check to see that it is '''up to date''' and if it isn't your own article, make sure it is of a '''current member''' through the [[Fleet Roster]]. Then, see if it includes the following:
Thinking of nominating an article? Check to see that it is '''up to date''' and if it isn't your own article, make sure it is of a '''current member''' through the [[Fleet Roster]]. Then ideally, see if it includes the following:


{| cellspacing="3"  
{| cellspacing="3"  

Latest revision as of 03:58, 7 July 2016

Featured Bio Contest
Featured-bios.jpg






This Month's Winner

Rahman3.jpg
Rahman
USS Veritas
Edit this Nav

All articles nominated for consideration in the Featured Bio Contest are judged using the contest's Judging Criteria as a guide. The winning bio does not need to meet all aspects of the criteria, but past winners tend to exhibit these elements.

Preface

The purpose of giving you this list of items isn't to stifle your creativity with your articles. In deciding just what should be considered the ideal for this contest, all ship/station rosters were surveyed to see how different members have chosen to present their characters. The following list represents some of the common elements noted across the board, yet the end result can and is often quite different and individual. For instance, consider the following three articles:

Each of these articles includes the elements listed in the criteria yet each showcases the character in a distinct fashion. If anything, we hope the criteria may perhaps inspire you and other members to expand your articles in a way that will let any reader learn more about your characters and the adventures that they have had during their time in our fleet.

Inquiries about the criteria may be posted in this thread in the contest's forum.

Good luck!

-Featured Bio Contest Team

Judging Criteria for Featured Articles

The ideal featured bio...

  1. Must be of a player character played by a current and active member.
  2. Must be either a primary or secondary player character. PNPCs are ineligible.
  3. Includes information about the character that is current as of the submission date.
  4. Includes both a link to the character’s current ship in the first sentence of the article and a template box with the current ship’s roster at the bottom of the article.
  5. Includes an appearance section.
  6. Includes a relationships section with a link to at least one different simmer’s player character.
  7. Includes some description of the character’s background, personality, or career history.
  8. Includes a full professional history of the character, showing rank progression, previous duty posts, and previous assignments.
  9. Includes an awards section showing any awards or service ribbons the character has received if applicable. This section should also include links to the “List of Awards” and “Service Ribbons” articles. The links may be incorporated into the section heading, as part of a table subheading, or listed separately.
  10. Includes links to at least two (2) selected sims written from the character’s perspective.
  11. Is properly categorized into at least the following five categories:
    1. Characters
    2. Affiliation (e.g., Starfleet personnel, Civilians)
    3. Ship/Station PCs (e.g., Avandar PCs)
    4. Profession (e.g., HCO Officers, Scientists)
    5. Species (e.g., Vulcans, Caitians)

Detailed Explanation of Criteria

1. Must be of a player character played by a current and active member.

  • Although there are many articles created by inactive or retired members that are worthy of being featured, we should showcase the work of our current members in the interest of fostering community spirit.


2. Must be either a primary or secondary player character. PNPCs are ineligible.

  • Likewise, while some members have created articles for their PNPCs that are just as complete as those made for their PCs, we wish to showcase only the player characters our members use in their simming to both encourage other members and inspire those who may wish to join.


3. Includes information about the character that is current as of the submission date.


4. Includes both a link to the character’s current ship in the first sentence of the article and a template box with the current ship’s roster at the bottom of the article.


5. Includes an appearance section.

  • While many of our members create images of their characters, we understand if others cannot or do not wish to do so. However, the article still must include information on the character’s appearance. The simmer may decide how much information they wish to include, but they must include at least one description such as height.


6. Includes a relationships section with a link to at least one different simmer’s player character.

  • Again, the purpose of this project is to feature our members and our community, encouraging both current and prospective members to learn more about our group. One of the best ways to do this is to encourage them to explore the SB118 Wiki itself.
  • A relationships section that includes information about friendships or romances should include at least one link to a different simmer’s primary/secondary player character (again, not a PNPC).
  • The linked character’s article does not need to meet the featured article criteria.


7. Includes some description of the character’s background, personality, or career history.

  • Of course, we don’t want featured articles to just be a list of facts and awards. There should be some written description of either the character’s backstory or time since they’ve been in the SB118 fleet.
  • Ideally, readers should be able to get just from reading the descriptive text a sense of what kind of person the character is and what kind of adventures and missions he or she has had since joining SB118. The tables or chronological listing of past assignments in the professional history should be used more as a supplement to the text.
  • Again, we want to inspire existing members who might be looking for new ideas in their own plots, and we want to let prospective members know what kind of adventures they could be having as well! Descriptive text also helps maintain a history of our group.


8. Includes a full professional history of the character, showing rank progression, previous duty posts, and previous assignments.

  • Showing the professional history of the character shows both other members and prospective members how each of our simmers started at ensign and worked their way up to their current rank.
  • Note, while this is the reasoning to include this criterion, the professional history does not necessarily have to match the actual professional history of the simmer in the event that the featured article character is a secondary or a replacement primary character. A “fictional” professional history leading to their first SB118 ship/station is acceptable.


9. Includes an awards section showing any awards or service ribbons the character has received if applicable. This section should also include links to the “List of Awards” and “Service Ribbons” articles. The links may be incorporated into the section heading, as part of a table subheading, or listed separately.

  • Our Fleet Awards are a proud tradition to recognize our members. Including this section should encourage more members to learn about the awards and nominate their fellow members for consideration when the annual awards ceremony approaches.


10. Includes links to at least two (2) selected sims written from the character’s perspective.

  • Links to selected sims from the character’s perspective may either by listed within the descriptive text or listed in either a subsection of the character history or a separate section entirely.


11. Is properly categorized into at least the following five categories:

  1. Characters
  2. Affiliation (e.g., Starfleet personnel, Civilians)
  3. Ship/Station PCs (e.g., Avandar PCs)
  4. Profession (e.g., HCO Officers, Scientists)
  5. Species (e.g., Vulcans, Caitians)
  • Categories are an integral part of the organizational structure of the wiki and help users navigate the wiki to find related pages.
  • In addition to the five categories above, there are other categories that may be appropriate for a character that can be added at the member's discretion (e.g., Ronin Alumni, GLBT Characters).

Quick Checklist of the Criteria

Thinking of nominating an article? Check to see that it is up to date and if it isn't your own article, make sure it is of a current member through the Fleet Roster. Then ideally, see if it includes the following:

  1. Introductory sentence with a link to the PC's ship.
  2. Ship's roster template box at the bottom of the article.
  3. Full professional history.
  4. Appearance section.
  5. Relationships section with a link to at least one different simmer’s PC.
  6. Awards section (if applicable) with links to the “List of Awards” and “Service Ribbons” articles.
  7. Descriptive text of the PC's background, personality, or career history in SB118.
  8. Links to at least two sims.
  9. Categorized into the five required categories.

If so, then nominate it for the current round in the contest's forum!